Home About Us
About Jigyasa IAS Mission & Vision Director’s Message
UPSC CSE
About Civil Services Examination Eligibility Criteria for CSE CSE Exam Pattern How to prepare for CSE How to choose optional subject
Courses
GS Foundation Course Sociology Optional Courses Guided Preparation Module Daily Rigorous Answer Writing
Daily Feeds
Daily Current Affairs Editorials Daily Quiz Free Answer Writing
Useful Links
About Prelims About Mains About Interview Daily Study Guideline Essential Book List
Downloads
NCERT Book List Govt. Welfare Schemes Daily Downloads
Contact Us
Blog Login

Constitutional Silences,Unconstitutional Inaction.

INDIAN POLITY
27 Dec, 2022

NEWS HIGHLIGHT 

Theme : State Legislature -Structure, organization, functioning.
Paper:GS - 2

When the Constitution was adopted by the Constituent Assembly, deliberate gaps were left for a future Parliament to modify and amend the Constitution in accordance with the aspirations and the will of the people.

 

TABLE OF CONTENT

  1. Context
  2. Article-200
  3. What is the Issue with the Article-200 and How is it Misused ?
  4. Purushothaman Nambudiri vs State of Kerala (1962)
  5. Article-201
  6. Suggestions
  7. Road Ahead


Context : When the Constitution was adopted by the Constituent Assembly, deliberate gaps were left for a future Parliament to modify and amend the Constitution in accordance with the aspirations and the will of the people.

Article-200 : 

  • It deals with the powers of the Governor with regard to assent given to bills passed by the State legislature and other powers of the Governor such as reserving the bill for the President’s consideration.
  • Bill passed by the Legislature of a State, is presented to the Governor, he has four options:
  • He assents to the Bill
  • He withholds assent
  • He reserves the Bill for the consideration of the President
  • He returns the Bill to the Legislature for reconsideration.
  • The Governor of India enjoys:
  • Absolute veto
  • Suspensive veto (except on money bills).

What is the Issue with the Article-200 and How is it Misused ?

  • Article-200 does not prescribe a timeline for the Governor to provide assent to Bills sent by the Legislative Assembly.

Instances Governors misused Article 200:

  • Tamil Nadu Prohibition of Online Gambling and Regulation of Online Games Bill, 2022 (passed by the Tamil Nadu Assembly)
  • Kerala Lok Ayukta (Amendment) Bill, 2022
  • In Tamil Nadu, almost 20 Bills are awaiting assent by the Governor.

Purushothaman Nambudiri vs State of Kerala (1962) : 

  • The SC said that the Constitution does not impose any time limit within which the Governor should provide assent to Bills.
  • Governors must honor the will of the Legislature
  • The President or a Governor can act only in harmony with their Council of Ministers.
  • Causing delay to assent Bills will be an arbitrary exercise, which is constitutionally unacceptable.

Article-201 : 

  • It pertains to ‘Bills Reserved for Consideration of the President.
  • There is no timeline prescribed for the President to decide on the outcome of the Bill.
  • There is a timeline of six months applicable to the State Assembly to reconsider the Bill if the President decides to refer it back to the House.
  • Instance of President withholding his assent : National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET)-exemption Bill passed by the Tamil Nadu Assembly.

Suggestions : 

  • Justice B.P. Jeevan Reddy-led Committee: It states that if the Governor withholds assent to a Bill indefinitely, “such a course will not be conducive with the decorous regard a Governor is expected to follow the rules of the Constitutional game
  • The ‘National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution: There should be a time-limit within which the Governor should take a decision whether to grant assent or to reserve a Bill for consideration of the President.
  • State government’s opinion before the Sarkaria Commission: “Governor will act as a safety-valve against hasty legislations and by their operation enable the State Government and Legislature to have a second look at it.
  • The Sarkaria Commission:
  • Delay from the side of the Governor in granting assent can be avoided by streamlining the existing procedures.
  • Making prior consultation with the Governor at the stage of the drafting of the Bill itself, and by prescribing time-limits for its disposal.

Road Ahead : 

  • An Independent Governor is necessary to act as a check and balance, to avoid the state-enacted law being repugnant to the Union laws.
  • Governor will have to grant assent or decline the same within a ‘reasonable time:‘Reasonable time is necessary, under the circumstances, to do conveniently what the contract or duty requires should be done in a particular case.
  • Keisham Meghachandra Singh vs The Hon’ble Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly (2020): The Supreme Court held that the Speaker must act on disqualification petitions against the defecting MLAs within a ‘reasonable time’.

FAQs : 

  1. What is Article-200?

ANS. It deals with the powers of the Governor with regard to assent given to bills passed by the State legislature and other powers of the Governor such as reserving the bill for the President’s consideration.

  1. What is Article-201?

ANS. It pertains to ‘Bills Reserved for Consideration of the President’.